Easy fellas lol...
Good debate going on in here, some valid arguments from both sides by my count
Let's not let it degenerate though!
I agree with BigSm0 on there being a lot of LED marketing fluff that hasn't really been challenged enough over the years (but I do think that's changing and will continue to change as the technology grows and becomes more main stream, consumers will simply demand more of the truth and hopefully we'll see some standards regulated.)
I also agree with Fairlynew, if a grow light can be had for next to nothing (compared to a higher end LED model) and it grows well, that
IS a good investment to most people and kind of substantiates that it's not always about what's written on a product spec sheet. Not everyone is ready for a push-up wonder bra, instead they want to ease into it with the Hello Kitty training bra. When they feel more comfortable, then they go for the upgrades. In my opinion, I think a lot of consumers/growers have that mentality.
People buy these and grow stellar plants all the time. Does it make is a good purchase? Not in the least. My info here is only to help enlighten people of the truth about lights. Not claims but the hard facts. It's not about previous grows, buddies grows, YouTube grows it's about plants need light and the light companies lead people to believe that LEDs are some miracle like the picture below. Having a light that can produce more and use less boils down to efficiency and efficiency only.
View attachment 575895
If people grow great plants under a cheap light, how is that not a good purchase? If the INFORMATION for the light is bad, I can see an argument there, but it's tough to say something that works for cheap is a
bad thing. I also disagree with the sentiment towards past grows. That's actually why this community EXISTS, brother
. So we can chronicle grow journals and people can see for themselves the setups that growers have and how well things work for them. I say it a lot on here, we're a "proof is in the pudding" kind of site, and if you put up, it usually shuts people up. Leaves little wiggle for argument when you have glaring documented photo evidence that something does indeed work.
If your argument is about the marketing that promotes the said lights, then I would have to agree with you. The amount of crap lights purchased on Amazon that people come on here saying "why doesn't this WORK?" Very frustrating. Of course, companies find other ways to promote their lights other than wild claims too, including sending members to grow sites and bragging up their lights with little to no journal activity. That's why we work together as a community to push through the muck
Anyway, just giving my two cents (and it's pure opinion, feel free to disagree!) Having a hot cup of coffee and thought I'd chime in