Thank you @mcpd_refugee for this post, i will be re-reading this over and over...
When it comes to to LED's I'm a trial and error kinda guy. I think I get what your saying and the more i read it it makes more sense but is it really more of a rule of thumb to go by? and go with that green finger gut feeling.
Some of those auto's real do need a lot less light and I've seen a massive difference from strain to strain in the same tent over a quite a few grows, even between genotype's. On one grow I did a full tent (6 of each) of GG4 (fastbuds) and G14 (fast buds). The GG4 shied away from the light and I had loads of light issues, cal mag etc. Now the G14 showed now signs of stress and grew to with in 5" from the cobs, lapping the light up like it was going out of fashion. Not one issue with the G14... those observation's are made with citizen 1212's at 3000/3500k, 1400ma and 1050ma.
Different story with my photo periods, not had an issue's yet apart from they get under the light for the first week and they are getting used to it from a T5.
So...it could be that the DLI and PPFD requirements are different between autos and photos. It could also be the the DLI and PPFD are strain dependent.
In any event, you have to read your plants, know exactly what that the issue is your light and not a deficiency or toxicity issue and make trial and error adjustments of your light. I guess I’ll just chalk it up to yet another piece of knowledge I have to hang onto in my inadequate knowledge storehouse.