They act pretty similar.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5607a/5607a2b904b3b3b164e9de62c781b658047ff904" alt="Thumbsup :thumbsup: :thumbsup:"
If I were to use some sort of automated watering device, it would probably be the carrot and some drip tape. The way I run earth boxes and the way I would run a system with a carrot, I have a dry down period. In an organic soil set up, I think a dry down. Is necessary for optimal health.