I previously used a generic carbon filter, I bought on ebay. Lasted about 1.5 years. I replaced it with one from I-Power. Both in the 6' size, and both have worked great, so far. The only time I smelled anything, was when i had a small hole in my duct, inside the room, and at the end of the first filters life. Prior to using carbon scrubbers, I ducted into a bucket with water and Pinesol. It worked, but I really got tired of the smell of Pinesol.
Ridgerunner