New Grower A need for more Constructive Critisism

[gearbear]

I didn't figure so. It's cool. I just tried to read between all the lines and come to resolution on this. It's all chill bro! Thanks for the killer thread you started on your methods too!

 

[EagleEyes]

Great post! For my first grow I got nothing but encouragement from everyone and it was nice. But there was a few times I hoped and asked for advice and it did seem most where scared to say anything. IMO Constructive Criticism is how we learn in all areas of life. The key word is Constructive You can let someone know they are making mistakes if you do it in a positive way. As for other sites I found it was mostly just Criticism and thats what everyone ran from. IMO

Thats just my 2 cents hope everyone has a great day.

 

[gearbear]

Ban SHACKO! EVIL!

JK, yup. I can agree with that. It's a fine line this subject. OH well.
I think there were several ways to take it and it's kinda threatening to have someone test what you are trying to do or Give Constructive Criticism about a possible need of more constructive criticism. I think most wanted to know, Is the statement really constructive in it's purpose is the reason for so many jumping on and defending the "good attitude" reputation and it's place.

Yea, Dr. A was just saying we need to be careful what we post. It's not all about patting everyone on the back and accidentally letting someone in need actually think they are doing good. I can say I might be to blame some of the time for that very thing. I try to keep up with grows and I want most to know I'm watching and encouraging words seem to be an easy way to say, hey I stopped in but it could be misleading to a grower to thinking they are really doing a great job.

I still need constructive criticism. I still believe I suck as a canna grower. I love to keep trying and experimenting though.

 

[HomieHogleg]

Just an idea.

If you see a problem with someones grow, and you can help. PM them your observations, and your advice. Then let them know that you would like to share the info in the thread, and see how that goes. Seems to make sense to me, to fix the problem privately first, and then spread the word.

Just my .02
Homie
P.S. Thanks Dr.Autoflower, for pointing me to this forum, and your informative autoflower videos on youtube.

 

[Joe Dirt]

If you see a problem with someones grow, and you can help. PM them your observations, and your advice. Then let them know that you would like to share the info in the thread, and see how that goes. Seems to make sense to me, to fix the problem privately first, and then spread the word.

If you're really concerned with an issue you can help with, this is the unselfish way to handle it. The new grower gets help... no glory or self promotion, but the person who needs help, gets it.