Even if 1000% exactly the same there is obv a reason they make 1 in an already broken down version! Its because its for a different use! 1 to sit long term in standing water (til it starts to disintegrate apparently lol) and 1 in pieces ready to go into soil or quickly absorbed into water for rapid kill of larvae! If u let bits sit in water and a dunk both for couple hours the dunk water will still be clear and the jugs with bits its turning a shade of brown from the bti transferring to the water already!