My point wasn't that you specifically buy into that stigma, but that blaming such acts on mental health is indeed harmful to those of us (you, I, plenty of others in the LS crew, along with millions of others) who live with mental health issues. I don't know that I'm particularly in the headspace to properly explain what I mean, but "normal" folks already see people with mental health issues as volatile/weird/less than/etc, and it's taken decades of advocacy to chip away even a little bit at the shame and harmful stereotypes surrounding diagnosis/treatment/MHI in general.
Think of just how commonplace words that are degrading to those with MHI are part of all of our vocabulary. Retard (down syndrome), crazy (several conditions), idiot (down syndrome/IQ impairment), dumb (of deaf and dumb), bipolar (self explanatory though generally used in the same way as crazy), psycho (psychopath, but again used like crazy), the list goes on and on. All used in diagnostics at one point or another, oftentimes antiquated terms that are generally used in a negative way in order to put someone down.
Idk. It's hard for me to see people I respect, genuinely care about, and consider good friends say things that are harmful to others (regardless of if its intended or not). I'm genuinely not mad or trying to start any sort of argument or anything like that, but I did figure it was worth mentioning.
Personally I believe it to be an incredibly complex issue in which mental health is absolutely a factor, but it is by no means the only one. That being said, if it were purely a matter of mental health what are we doing as a country to address that issue? How do we support mental health when treatment is incredibly cost prohibitive and those who need it most are very often unable to seek it?
I was my daughter's age when Columbine happened. Myself and my children have all grown up in a world where school is no longer a safe place to learn. Two, now three generations of children in this country have had to learn what to do, where to hide, how to be silent while in imminent danger. It's traumatizing and it absolutely has psychological effects.
Even if it never happens, you still have that anxiety every single day. What if today is the day? Every goodbye at the bus stop or drop off could be the last. I'm no expert, but living every day not knowing, on high alert at any loud noise in the school, the momentary frozen fear when the fire alarm goes off, and the traumatic repeated experience that is active shooter drills, those have got to be breeding their own special type of mental illness. Entire generations living with complex PTSD because the grown ups who are supposed to keep them safe refuse to do anything at all to hold up their end of the bargain.
There is no easy fix to such a complex and complicated issue, but not doing anything at all certainly isn't the answer.