It should have been. This is the story. Hail damage, insurance settlement, home owner took the money, tacked on new layer of shingles with no prep. He had already done the house, but I stopped him doing the garage, and made him remove the old (double layer) before continuing. The house roof is wooden, not plywood, which is cool. But a few boards are rotten here and there. I have nearly completely renovated this house otherwise. All new plumbing, electric, and heat/air, ducts, added laundry bump out, french drains, new basement piers, new kitchen floor joists sub floor, painted everything, and put knee walls and a floor in the attic. Almost all me too, the only things I didn't do were the duct and plumbing new installs.