My only claim is that there is as yet no scientific consensus that the products are safe, this was restated by 300 scientists on 1 Feb at ENSSER and one of the signatories, Nicolas Defarge, had this to say:
”Progress in science occurs through controversial debate involving scientific arguments. Our statement, peer-reviewed and published in the open access literature, is now one of them. The debate about the health effects of the long-term consumption of GMOs and of the residues of pesticides they contain is ongoing. It can only be solved by further studies using accurate protocols enabling the investigation of long-term effects. These must be published in open access journals with the raw data being made available and not kept secret. We should bear in mind that the studies performed by industry to support the release of GMOs on the market are usually not peer-reviewed at the time the GMO is commercialized.”
(1)
The science is ongoing, and as it happens there are an equal number of scientists trying to find health risks as there are trying to disprove it. And it's worth noting that a statistically substantial number of the studies trying to disprove any health risks are funded by biotechnology.
(2)
I think it's really important that we as an international community wholeheartedly endorse responsible science to take place, but use extreme caution in allowing these products to come to market in the interim. You might be surprised to find that the FDA has done absolutely no formal testing on genetically engineered foods and has still stated they are "substantially equivalent".
(3)
Anyway, that I think is all I have to contribute since my views aren't going to change without substantial science coming in. I do think it's an important international conversation to have, and I hope that we look to our scientists for the answers while respecting that even after the science comes in there might be many people who would be more comfortable with reasonable labeling because at the end of the day freedom of choice is what makes being human worth it.