Im pretty sure there is nothing that you did wrong to cause this, as well as nothing you could have done to prevent it. Some seeds are just mutants, or sickly, or off in some way. This looks to be one of those type of seedlings. The feed you described giving it doesn't has any npk values so that's not the issue.. It may grow out if it, it may not. It's hard to say. But I would keep doing exactly what you're doing and let it grow out a little more. Some plants outgrow the problems they had as seedlings.
And that 7.2 ph you posted.. Is that the soil ph or the ph of your feed/water?
And that 7.2 ph you posted.. Is that the soil ph or the ph of your feed/water?