Grow Mediums Fabric, air, or plastic pots?

The filter that Autopot supplies is better than nothing, I can give them that much. But in my opinion it suffers from two serious limitations. First it is so small that its capacity is negligible. If for any reason there is stuff in your reservoir, it can plug with not much junk. Second, the filtration it accomplishes is coarse, and it will let too much smaller diameter stuff into your lines, and that could accumulate in the lines or the valves and cause mischief. All opinion on my part, but I can tell you that my setup sorted a long grow with zero issues with the autopot system, and my reservoir was full of junk the whole time because I was using stream and lake water with significant amounts of organic debris in it.

There are lots of ways to skin this cat, I have used two. Last winter, with my ~10 gallon reservoir, I wedged a common pleated filter element over the reservoir outlet as shown in these photos:

View attachment 1213000View attachment 1212998View attachment 1212999

Note that by wedging the way that I did, the only way water can get out of the reservoir is to go through the filter first. Both ends of the common filter elements are open, so the far end from the outlet needs to be sealed one way or another in order for this to work. I had the fairly dense white foam I used sitting around (bit of a diy pack rat, I admit), but if you need foam, one of the pool noodles would work fine if you cut it to the lengths needed.

In my garden this summer, I used a 45 gallon reservoir which is a lot wider than the 10 gallon one, so rather than wedging the element like the setup in the pics, I adapted the filter element so it would screw into the bulkhead fitting I used to install a tap on the barrel. The filter element is still on the inside of the barrel, just mounted with a pipe thread, not wedged. I don't have pics of that setup, but you get the idea.

You could also just buy the entire filter housing sold for this sort of filter and install in on your line, but if you do that, install it downstream from your reservoir tap/valve so that you can maintain it if needed without draining the reservoir. Unlikely that you will need to do anything with it though, its capacity is far larger than any likely loading unless you are fooling around with some really nasty organic stuff. And it will not let anything that is not dissolved or seriously tiny into your lines or valves.

Just my take on it, but it works well for me. Good luck with your grow, I expect you will like the autopot system if you give it a try. :pighug:
That brass fitting is a no no. You can leach way to much copper and cause a toxicity.
 
You can buy the fabric pot/autopot setup directly from the Autopot website. The one that they sell is their XL tray with a fabric smart pot which fits inside the tray perfectly. The pots supplied are nominally 5 gallon and on the tall side. I rolled the rims of mine down and filled them with only ~3 gallons of coco/perlite mix. You certainly do not need anything larger than that. Smaller would likely work just fine too, but I just used the supplied pots. This setup will grow them big, so watch your strain if your space is limited. You can see pics of the results in the grow and review in my sig.

Thank you for the recommendations, My 9 smartpot autopot xl kit should be arriving tomorrow and I will be setting it up this weekend!
9 Mephisto Reserva girls in my 5x5 with 2x HLG-320W-XL-v2 will be the maiden voyage.

Just got to make up my mind on the nute line...
 
Thank you for the recommendations, My 9 smartpot autopot xl kit should be arriving tomorrow and I will be setting it up this weekend!
9 Mephisto Reserva girls in my 5x5 with 2x HLG-320W-XL-v2 will be the maiden voyage.

Just got to make up my mind on the nute line...
MCIII would be my vote for starters, but what do I know? Any of the recognized lines work in careful hands, but MC packs a lot of goods for the price. I am tempted to get some of the new stuff, and use the MCII I have for the first part of the grow. Decisions, decision. OTOH, not sucking on a ventilator, allows one a certain degree of focus... :biggrin: :pighug:
 
@derek420colorado @Olderfart
Ready to pull the trigger on Megacrop A+B, just a couple questions. Any suggestions on additives? Are they needed? I will be using coco.
I have a little experience with MC in the past but it was in soil and didn't go well. I used MC1.0 for a run and 2.0 for a run. Both runs faced deficiencies but the the nutes had absorbed humidity and I am sure that was affecting my weights while measuring.
 
@derek420colorado @Olderfart
Ready to pull the trigger on Megacrop A+B, just a couple questions. Any suggestions on additives? Are they needed? I will be using coco.
I have a little experience with MC in the past but it was in soil and didn't go well. I used MC1.0 for a run and 2.0 for a run. Both runs faced deficiencies but the the nutes had absorbed humidity and I am sure that was affecting my weights while measuring.
All I got was the sea K
 
@derek420colorado @Olderfart
Ready to pull the trigger on Megacrop A+B, just a couple questions. Any suggestions on additives? Are they needed? I will be using coco.
I have a little experience with MC in the past but it was in soil and didn't go well. I used MC1.0 for a run and 2.0 for a run. Both runs faced deficiencies but the the nutes had absorbed humidity and I am sure that was affecting my weights while measuring.
I can't advise from experience either re. additives, or the A-B version of MC. Having said that, some kelp seems like a good idea to me, it has growth hormones and lots of micronutes, and seems very unlikely to cause problems.

You may need cal mag as well, so I would have some handy even though the two part has quite a bit of it. Coco can be a bit of a bitch with Calcium and Magnesium, and some strains are worse than others.

The two part version seems like an interesting alternative. If it contains all the micronutes and other good stuff in the single part, I would go for it as well. In theory at least it should allow adjustment of nutes between growth and bloom, which the single part does not permit as easily.

Good luck with the grow. :pighug:
 
Last edited:
I can't advise from experience either re. additives, or the A-B version of MC. Having said that, some kelp seems like a good idea to me, it has growth hormones and lots of micronutes, and seems very unlikely to cause problems.

You may need cal mag as well, so I would have some handy. Coco can be a bit of a bitch with Calcium and Magnesium, and some strains are worse than others.

Is there a reason that you are going with the two part MC rather than version III of the one part? Just curious, not questioning your decision.
I assumed you were referring to the 2 part line when you said MCII and thought it was a typo when you listed MCIII. I didnt realize they were on version 3.0 now. The last time I ran some they just released v2.0. Any idea what they changed from 2.0 to 3.0?

Cal-mag is a staple in my room, it is always on hand.
 
I assumed you were referring to the 2 part line when you said MCII and thought it was a typo when you listed MCIII. I didnt realize they were on version 3.0 now. The last time I ran some they just released v2.0. Any idea what they changed from 2.0 to 3.0?

Cal-mag is a staple in my room, it is always on hand.
You are right, I was originally referring to the version III single part. As I understand it, the main differences are more calcium and less potassium, and more consistent physical particle size (no more white balls) but there are likely other differences as well. Although MC has been criticized for changing their formula so often, I give them big credit for listening to feedback and trying to improve their product. This sort of performance, particularly at the price they provide, is beyond top notch in my books.

Anyway, if I needed more MC, I would be much tempted by the two part. OTOH, I am not really sure that I do enough growing or know enough about this stuff to improve on the performance of the one part mix. The one part stuff already works really well, and dialing it will be simpler for us home growers than fiddling with the mix of two part.

I don't think you can go too far wrong with either approach, and more experienced peeps on here may be happy to help with dialing the two part if you need some advice. :pighug:
 
Back
Top