Hmmm I can't say for sure buddy.... there were some really nice plants both ways BUT I have never grown the same strain twice... and I have used everything from t5 to 600w hps and now on LED so the variations have been crazy but ide say as long as the feed and setup are dialed in either way is gonna produce a game winner....
I may actually go back to full pot soaking..... growing pot was a relaxing hobby that way but these days it's a job near bout....