So thanks to @Mañ'O'Green it's back to the store
Until I get squared away, I added a teaspoon of cal mag per gallon and left it overnight. It ph'd at about 5.6 so I added half a teaspoon of ph up...
If your target number is 8.2, I highly recommend that recipe
So on the second gallon, ten drops brought me to 6.4.
Tonight I plan to do some trimming, but maybe I'll just get a little high and watch The Big Lebowski
pH up and down are super touchy, and it seems the pH up is the touchiest. I always have to down but 1ml will drop my pH from 6.2-5.8 in 4 gallons