Thanks
@mcpd_refugee for chiming in.
There's no opinion here that's unwanted, everybody's insight is useful and appreciated.
First off, overwatering isn't the issue here. I'm not sure it would be possible in my mix to be honest. I think the SNs are just a little more hungry than the 4AM. There is clawing rather than drooping, it's minor but I want to catch any potential issues as early as I can.
in short, I agree with
@Medimadness on the issue of topping. It really does seem to be a controversial one though!
There were a few reasons I decided to top this one. Mostly I'm just curious and want to see what happens. I have two plants of this strain on the go and it seemed like a good opportunity to experiment and run a side by side comparison. I also think the structure actually lends itself very well to the technique. Yes it will create an even bushier structure but will also allow a little more room to play as the other untopped SN basically can't be trained at all.
I would usually train a plant by bringing the dominant growth down and letting the rest of the growth reach upwards thus creating an even canopy. It just isn't possible to do that with this plant. By topping her, she was immediately exposed to much more light and as far as I can tell, more light = more tops and more tops = more buds.
I don't think that topping will create a longer growth period. I might be wrong, but I've never seen this happen. Sure, it might create a smaller plant in the long run but I'd be surprised if it affected the timeline too much. We'll see!
As far as breeders recommendations go, I've never seen one recommend topping an auto, I don't think Mephisto even really recommend LST on any of their strains which is clearly not always the best advice. I take breeder info with a pinch of salt.
The stems are relatively thick on the SN, but just as flexible as any others really, I train them very slowly and gently, I've never had a stem snap on me during this stage and hopefully I won't this time around either. I'm pretty careful with it and don't really mind if it create more work. There's not really that much to do in the garden so a little more work here and there is welcome really. I love spending time with my plants and relish the opportunity to get on with little tasks here and there.
Anyway, the main point that I'm making is that it's an experiment and therefore there is no bad outcome as far as I'm concerned, just an opportunity to learn and so far, the topped plant is looking much better than the untopped one.