Deep Water Culture Basics - Bubbleponics

Sharing some things I have learned doing Deep Water Culture with cannabis.

Technically what I use is called “Bubbleponics”. First your environmental needs must be met - light, temperature, humidity and air movement all need to be in range for plants to grow well. I will assume you understand these basic concepts. The rules for a good DWC are simple but not very forgiving. Plants respond adversely quickly to something out of range. The good thing is that they will also respond well to a correction quickly. DWC is an everyday task; in fact checking your plants many times a day can keep you ahead of needs.

Two tools that you cannot do without are a good PH meter and a EC meter; both should be equipped with a temperature gauge as well. Maintain them and replace them on the vendor’s schedule.

The five basic components:

1. Water. You could spend a lifetime trying to learn about water for plant growth but let’s keep it simple. Most people can use their tap water as long as the beginning PPM is 200 or less. If your water goes over this you will need to mix it with distilled or Reverse Osmosis water to get it below 200 PPM. Use a float valve and top off bucket to keep the water level in your reservoir consistent even small fluctuations can cause stress. Set the water level 1” – ½” below the bottom of your net pot. Aerate your water for a day or two before you intend to use it. This will help precipitate calcium carbonate out of the water and make it easier to control your PH. I just use my top off tank for this. The perfect reservoir water temperature is 68°F. This is the temperature that water holds the most dissolved oxygen. Do not use copper, brass or aluminum anywhere in your system; not even the tiniest fitting.

2. Air. Roots need air. An aquarium air pump and air stones provide this critical component. I always use two pump/stone combos for redundancy. Losing aeration even for a short period can be problematic. The smaller the bubbles are coming out of the stones the better. I use a UPS battery back-up on my air pumps. The volume of airflow needs to be high enough to saturate the water but not be so violent that the roots are damaged. Smaller bubbles allow more airflow with less violence.

3. Nutrients. Just make this a no brainer. Unless you have a lab and the skills to use it; choose ONE nutrient vendor whose products are built from the ground up for cannabis hydroponics and use their entire line. Do not mix and match. Vendors spend millions of dollars and years developing their products to work with each other. Take advantage of that. Follow their feeding schedule. Change the water/nutrient solution every week – without fail. Learn about Liebig’s law of the Minimum to understand why you are doing this. Look at the Liebig’s Barrel to visualize what we are talking about here. DO NOT MIX NUTRENTS INTO THE RESERVOIR; mix them in a separate container using water that has been aerated for a day or two following vendor instructions the day before the reservoir refresh. Doing this ahead of time will make it much easier to get the PH balanced and stable. A suction pump will be worth its weight in gold to help evacuate the reservoir for a refresh. Many product lines can and should be used at 50% of the vendor’s chart strengths in DWC but not all of them. Do a little research on your chosen brand.

4. PH. PH has absolutely everything to do with the uptake of nutrients into the plant. Let it range from 5.7 to 6.2 in DWC. This will allow the different components to move through the best uptake zones for that nutrient. Check the PH every day even multiple times per day is better. Roots not only take water and nutrients in they also exude substances that can dramatically change the PH in the reservoir in a very short period of time. I am talking hours here not days. Mix PH buffers into some water before adding to the reservoir to prevent burning the roots. Make small changes at a time. One full point is too much (5.2 to 6.2). It takes practice and vigilance to maintain PH in the proper range. PH problems have caused me more issues than all of the other environmental factors combined. The minute you take your eye off this it will bite your plants in the ass!

5. Botanicare HydroGuard. The only additive outside of your chosen nutrient regime I recommend. It is a must have. I would not even buy a bucket before I had this in stock. Root Rot is totally preventable with this. I live where it is not possible to maintain the reservoir temperature below 78°F in the summertime and it has gone as high as 82°F. The ability for water to keep oxygen saturation at that high of a temperature is minimized. Think stagnant pond! I have grown great plants totally root rot free using HydroGuard under these conditions. High temperatures are not the only thing that can cause root problems. Botanicare HydroGuard is a basic component to DWC. I am not affiliated with or compensated in any way for this endorsement by anyone except my happy plants with huge colas.

I have tried several ways to get a plant started. Top feeding seeds planted in small rock wool cubes or Park’s Bio Dome sponges supported in the net pot by PH balanced clay pebbles until the roots get down into the reservoir a couple of inches has worked best for me. Then stop top feeding to prevent crown rot.

So there you have it. Now 10,000 people will take issue with something I have laid out here and I may agree with many of them. I have moved on to growing hydroponically in rock wool cubes because it solves my oxygenation problems associated with high summer reservoir temperatures. I am telling you now that if I did not have heat issues in the summer I would still be growing DWC!
 
Last edited:

    Bradtd89

    Points: 10
    For anyone who needs a quick refresh in doing DWC or even a fresh new beginner, your post is very helpful. Thank you. I have a similar system myself with the same temp problems where I live.

    VitaMan

    Points: 10
    Fist DWC. Made a lot of these mistakes....and found some of the solutions you wrote about.
I think that might be your issue, my bucket is 27l and I fill it with roughly 18l of solution to take it to just underneath the net pot and I have a 40lpm pump for 2 buckets so 20lpm per bucket although some people will say I'm going overboard but I've had 2 very successful grows and no sign of root rot either!
I shall take another photo of the roots later, they look alright. Growth been abit slow but thinks that’s down to me being a newbie idiot, I chopped leaves off a clone when it was was under a few weeks old and could have really done with them.
 
It is really not about how much air you are pumping into the reservoir it is about how much oxygen exchange is taking place. Large violent bubbles are very inefficient at exchanging oxygen while tiny soft bubbles are very efficient. Smaller bubbles are "softer" because the rise to the surface slower which is less violent and gives the air more contact time with the water for a better exchange rate. Here is a good article about the subject:
http://www.just4growers.com/stream/...truth-on-dissolved-oxygen-in-hydroponics.aspx
I'm definitely no expert and I'm not suggesting that he should go out and buy a large pump but I do think that his current pump is under powered, I would definitely go with 5-7lpm in a bucket but that's my 2 cents!
 
Good write up.

After years of side by side testing, and always looking for what works for me(a simple home grower who smokes an oz a week), and is the simplest, cheapest, and most effective. I've come up with a couple of things I'd add.

1. In addition to Hydroguard, Flying Skull's additive Z7 is a must. It's worth it just for how much cleaner my buckets are staying and I only use 2ml in each bucket on weekly water change days. When my season begins again next Sept I am going to run buckets with just the Z7 to see if I can do away with the Hydroguard. I've heard of people doing this successfully and if it works that's more $$ in my pocket.

2. Chasing pH is a PITA. Especially in 5 gallon buckets when your actual nutrient solution volume is more like 4 gallons. Do yourself a favor and spend a little more for Advanced Nutrients pH Perfect 3 part, and never bother with checking pH again.

Regarding the pH Perfect......I tested this many times, even went 18 months without a pH pen. It works. And it works at much lower dosage than they recommend. I average 5oz per plant in 90 days and never use more than 21ml/4gal. AN says to use 60ml/4gal. :haha: At lower dosages using tap water the pH going into the reservoir will be between 6.1 and 6.3 No worries, the chelation factor still allows for proper uptake. HOWEVER...for this to work like that, I always adjust my top off water to a pH of 6.0 , and change my reservoir every 7 days or sooner. If a plant has used 14-16qts since the last water change and the week isn't up yet...change the water! Don't wait for the regular day. This is where note taking is important.:jump:

That's my $0.02 :shooty:

DWC can be a very easy way to grow huge harvests . Just don't over think it. :growing:
Cheers good advice regarding the ph perfect. I was wondering why it kept going a little higher. Have you got a rough guide to how much you feed at each stage? I’m keeping the ec at about 1 using micro grow bloom rhino skin and about to make next res with big bud. Have you got any dwc journals? Cheers
 
I'm definitely no expert and I'm not suggesting that he should go out and buy a large pump but I do think that his current pump is under powered, I would definitely go with 5-7lpm in a bucket but that's my 2 cents!
Especially when those roots fill the bucket and cover the airstones!
 
I shall take another photo of the roots later, they look alright. Growth been abit slow but thinks that’s down to me being a newbie idiot, I chopped leaves off a clone when it was was under a few weeks old and could have really done with them.
@d.t I think you hit the nail on the head. I was going to bring this up earlier and got distracted. IMPO you have defoliated way too much. There are no leaves to make energy for the plant to grow. Another thing I noticed is the effect of the water level dropping in the reservoir. The area in the red circle has no side roots because they are drying out and dying off in the air. They most likely will never take in nutrients in that section again.
ScreenHunter_131 Aug. 28 13.34.jpg


This is what a healthy root system looks like. Notice the side branching roots start right below the net pot.

roots.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: d.t
E8878102-A736-4D45-8E06-80670C0099BB.jpeg
BE928D32-92C3-4949-A13D-703EF8102046.jpeg
52D441FE-8805-4842-9B67-9E4FB5DF3604.jpeg
Ah right yeah lessons learnt.
Got some problems here but not sure what. Theres a ‘rusty’ look on some of the older fan leaves. Could be from few possible things I want sorted. Guess it’s a ‘lockout’ or something to do with that rule of minimums?
Also could be caused from cold temps? I have no reservoir heater or Thermostat in there so no idea how cold it’s getting at night, soon it shall be really getting cold so need to get one ASAP.
Or from not changing the res often enough. Or something else.. finding it a massive chore changing the reservoir as it’s cramped and seems hugely wasteful using so many nutrients.
Makes me really appreciate the autopot only using what it needs.
Starting to flower though and most the leaves a nice dark green just don’t like this rusty nasty look at all.
 
View attachment 951324 View attachment 951323 View attachment 951322 Ah right yeah lessons learnt.
Got some problems here but not sure what. Theres a ‘rusty’ look on some of the older fan leaves. Could be from few possible things I want sorted. Guess it’s a ‘lockout’ or something to do with that rule of minimums?
Also could be caused from cold temps? I have no reservoir heater or Thermostat in there so no idea how cold it’s getting at night, soon it shall be really getting cold so need to get one ASAP.
Or from not changing the res often enough. Or something else.. finding it a massive chore changing the reservoir as it’s cramped and seems hugely wasteful using so many nutrients.
Makes me really appreciate the autopot only using what it needs.
Starting to flower though and most the leaves a nice dark green just don’t like this rusty nasty look at all.
You better turn that leaf over and look for bugs.
 
Screenshot_20180926-200745.png

Has anyone used this to cool their rez temps I've been looking into a way cool a 5gallon rez it's between this and a ice probe chiller
 
0BCC6A61-6F42-4F32-B3B6-FAC00231AA7C.jpeg
You better turn that leaf over and look for bugs.
Definitely no bugs. It’s some kind of deficiency but not sure what. Seems to get worse towards the end of the week before a fresh nutirent mix. The temps have been going way too low down to 8c so good chance it’s related to that, got a heater on the way for the next grow. This has been like a little lesson in dwc, so many mistakes lots learnt. Not bothered too much as main grow is her mum in soil and she’s doing ok, leaves a little pale but she’s smelling great. Here’s some more photos of the horrible leaves, it’s a rusty look and the leaves feel a bit dry and brittle.
 
Never had problems like this in soil. It could be some kind of micro deficiency but I’m changing the nutrients every week now so not sure why unless it’s the temperature. Il get a new pump soon as well, despite the troubles I have had i shall be re doing it as can’t quit it just because of some troubles, got to get something good out of these mistakes.
 
Last edited:

Test

Test
Back
Top